When renovating floors, homeowners often find themselves deciding between vinyl tile and vinyl plank flooring. Both options offer durability and water resistance, but they differ in appearance, installation methods, and cost. Vinyl tile mimics ceramic or stone while vinyl plank resembles hardwood, creating distinct aesthetic possibilities for your space. This comprehensive comparison explores the differences in pricing, installation requirements, leading manufacturers, and the advantages and limitations of each option. Understanding these factors will help you make an informed decision that aligns with your budget, design preferences, and practical needs.
Vinyl tile typically comes in square shapes, usually 12″Ã12″ or 18″Ã18″, and is designed to resemble ceramic tile, stone, or concrete. It’s available in peel-and-stick, glue-down, or interlocking formats. The most popular form today is luxury vinyl tile (LVT), which offers enhanced realism and durability compared to traditional vinyl tile.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Vinyl plank flooring comes in rectangular pieces that mimic hardwood planks, typically measuring 48″ or 36″ long by about 6″ wide. Luxury vinyl plank (LVP) represents the premium segment of this category. Both LVT and LVP are constructed in layers, including a wear layer, design layer, core layer, and backing. The thickness of the wear layer (measured in mils) is a crucial factor in determining the flooring’s longevity and price.
Price Comparison: Vinyl Tile vs. Vinyl Plank
Vinyl flooring prices vary widely based on quality, thickness, and installation type. Entry-level vinyl tile costs $0.50-$2 per square foot, while basic vinyl plank ranges from $1-$3 per square foot. Mid-range options for both typically run $2-$5 per square foot, with luxury versions reaching $5-$7+ per square foot.
Premium luxury vinyl tile and plank with thicker wear layers (20 mil or higher) can cost $7-$10 per square foot. Generally, vinyl plank tends to be slightly more expensive than comparable vinyl tile, often by $0.50-$1 per square foot, due to the manufacturing process and larger piece sizes.
| Quality Level | Vinyl Tile (per sq. ft.) | Vinyl Plank (per sq. ft.) |
|---|---|---|
| Basic | $0.50-$2.00 | $1.00-$3.00 |
| Mid-range | $2.00-$5.00 | $2.50-$5.50 |
| Premium | $5.00-$7.00 | $5.50-$10.00 |
Installation Costs and Methods
Professional installation for vinyl tile typically costs $2-$5 per square foot, while vinyl plank installation ranges from $1.50-$4 per square foot. The difference stems from the additional labor required for tile placement and pattern alignment. Peel-and-stick vinyl tile is the most DIY-friendly option, while click-lock vinyl plank offers relatively simple installation for moderately skilled homeowners.
Vinyl tile installation may require additional materials like adhesive and grout (for groutable LVT), adding $0.50-$1.00 per square foot. Vinyl plank often requires underlayment unless it’s built-in, adding $0.30-$0.70 per square foot. Subfloor preparation costs are similar for both options, ranging from $0.50-$2.00 per square foot depending on the condition of your existing floor.
DIY Installation Considerations
For DIY enthusiasts, vinyl plank with click-lock systems offers significant advantages. The installation is faster (approximately 20% quicker than tile) and requires fewer specialized tools. Vinyl tile, especially when grouted, requires more precision, patience, and specific tools like spacers, notched trowels, and possibly a tile cutter. However, peel-and-stick vinyl tile can be easier for small spaces or simple layouts.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Leading Brands in Vinyl Flooring
The vinyl flooring market features several respected manufacturers known for quality, innovation, and warranty coverage. Understanding the differences between these brands can help you select the best product for your needs.
Top Vinyl Tile Brands
- Armstrong Flooring: Offers extensive LVT lines including Alterna with realistic textures and premium designs ($4-$7 per sq ft)
- Mohawk: Known for SolidTech Plus tiles with enhanced durability and water resistance ($3.50-$6 per sq ft)
- Shaw Floors: Features DuraTru and Array collections with excellent stain resistance ($3-$5.50 per sq ft)
- Mannington: Adura Max tiles offer superior sound absorption and comfort underfoot ($4-$7 per sq ft)
Top Vinyl Plank Brands
- COREtec: Pioneered WPC (wood-plastic composite) core technology for enhanced stability ($4-$8 per sq ft)
- Karndean: Premium designs with exceptional realism and handcrafted looks ($5-$9 per sq ft)
- Cali Bamboo: Offers eco-friendly options with impressive durability ratings ($3.50-$7 per sq ft)
- LifeProof: Home Depot’s exclusive brand featuring excellent water resistance at competitive prices ($2.50-$4.50 per sq ft)
- NuCore: Floor & Decor’s house brand offering good value and waterproof properties ($2.50-$4 per sq ft)
Pros and Cons of Vinyl Tile
Advantages of Vinyl Tile
Vinyl tile excels in creating authentic stone and ceramic looks, often featuring realistic grout lines and textures. Its square format allows for various pattern layouts, including diagonal, checkerboard, and basketweave designs. Installation can be done in sections, making it easier to replace individual damaged tiles without disturbing the entire floor.
In bathrooms and kitchens, vinyl tile performs exceptionally well due to its water resistance and the ability to incorporate grout (in some LVT products), enhancing the ceramic tile appearance. Premium vinyl tiles often feature embossed textures that closely mimic natural materials, creating more convincing stone and ceramic reproductions than vinyl plank can achieve.
Disadvantages of Vinyl Tile
The individual tile format creates more seams compared to vinyl plank, potentially allowing more moisture to penetrate if not properly installed. Vinyl tile installation typically requires more precision and time, especially when aligning patterns or incorporating decorative pieces. Peel-and-stick varieties, while convenient, generally have shorter lifespans than glue-down or click-lock options.
When replicating wood looks, vinyl tile is less convincing than vinyl plank due to the visible seams that interrupt the natural wood grain pattern. Additionally, budget vinyl tiles tend to curl at the edges over time, particularly in high-moisture environments if not properly adhered to the subfloor.
Pros and Cons of Vinyl Plank
Advantages of Vinyl Plank
Vinyl plank creates the most realistic wood-look flooring in the vinyl category, with fewer visible seams than tile and authentic wood grain textures. Modern manufacturing techniques allow for embossed surfaces that match the visual grain patterns, enhancing the realism. The click-lock installation systems found in most vinyl planks create a floating floor that can be installed over existing surfaces, reducing preparation time.
The longer, wider format means faster installation in large spaces and fewer seams for moisture to penetrate. Many vinyl plank products now feature rigid cores (SPC or WPC) that hide subfloor imperfections better than vinyl tile and provide enhanced stability and dent resistance, crucial for active households.
Disadvantages of Vinyl Plank
Vinyl plank is less effective at replicating stone or ceramic looks compared to vinyl tile. The larger pieces can be more challenging to transport and manipulate in tight spaces or irregular room layouts. Cutting vinyl plank, especially rigid core varieties, requires more specialized tools like a vinyl cutter or jigsaw for precise fits around obstacles.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
When damage occurs, replacing a single plank in the middle of a floor can be more complicated than replacing a vinyl tile, sometimes requiring disassembly from the wall to the damaged area. Additionally, some floating vinyl plank installations can produce a hollow sound underfoot unless installed with a quality underlayment.
Which Option is Best for Different Spaces
Kitchen Considerations
For kitchens, both options perform well, but vinyl tile often edges out plank when seeking a ceramic or stone aesthetic. The ability to incorporate grout lines in LVT creates a more authentic tile look. Vinyl plank works excellently in kitchens that flow into living spaces, creating visual continuity throughout the home. Both materials stand up to spills and moisture, with premium products providing 100% waterproof protection.
Bathroom Applications
In bathrooms, vinyl tile traditionally holds an advantage, particularly groutable LVT that closely mimics ceramic tile. The smaller format makes it easier to work around fixtures and create proper slopes toward drains. However, waterproof vinyl plank with rigid cores now performs admirably in bathrooms as well, offering fewer seams where water can potentially penetrate.
Living Areas and Bedrooms
For living rooms, family rooms, and bedrooms, vinyl plank generally provides a warmer, more residential feel with its wood-look aesthetics. The longer planks create a sense of space, making rooms appear larger and more open. Vinyl tile can create distinctive looks in these spaces too, particularly when using large-format tiles or bold patterns for a contemporary design statement.
Commercial Spaces
In commercial environments, the choice often depends on the desired aesthetic and traffic patterns. Vinyl tile with high-performance wear layers (28+ mil) performs exceptionally well in high-traffic commercial settings, while vinyl plank can create a more upscale, residential feel in hospitality or retail environments. Many commercial installations leverage both products, using tile in entryways and bathrooms while installing plank in offices and common areas.