When choosing fencing materials for your property, composite and vinyl options stand out as popular alternatives to traditional wood. Both materials offer durability and low maintenance requirements, but they differ significantly in price, appearance, and performance characteristics. Composite fencing typically costs $25-$45 per linear foot installed, while vinyl ranges from $20-$35 per linear foot. This comprehensive guide explores their differences, helping you decide which material best suits your specific needs, aesthetic preferences, and budget constraints.
Composite fencing consists of a blend of recycled wood fibers and plastic polymers, creating a material that mimics the appearance of natural wood without its maintenance requirements. Most composite fence products contain 50-70% wood fibers mixed with polyethylene or PVC and additional binders and stabilizers. This composition delivers the aesthetic charm of wood while offering superior resistance to moisture, insects, and decay.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Unlike pure wood fences, composite options don’t require regular staining or sealing. They’re engineered to maintain their color and structural integrity through years of exposure to harsh weather conditions. Modern manufacturing techniques have significantly improved composite fencing, with many products featuring UV inhibitors that prevent fading and color loss over time.
Understanding Vinyl Fences
Vinyl fencing (also called PVC fencing) is made from polyvinyl chloride, a synthetic plastic material. High-quality vinyl fences contain impact modifiers, UV inhibitors, and titanium dioxide to enhance durability, prevent brittleness, and resist color fading. These additions significantly improve the material’s performance compared to early vinyl products that were prone to cracking and yellowing.
Modern vinyl fences are typically hollow inside with internal reinforcement chambers that provide structural strength while keeping the material lightweight. This design creates fencing that resists winds up to 70 mph or more when properly installed. Vinyl fencing comes in various styles, including privacy, picket, ranch, and ornamental designs, with the most common colors being white, tan, and gray.
Cost Comparison: Material Prices
When comparing material costs alone, vinyl and composite fencing show distinct price differences. Vinyl fencing materials typically cost $15-$25 per linear foot, while composite materials range from $20-$35 per linear foot. This price difference reflects composite’s more complex manufacturing process and the incorporation of wood fibers that give it a more natural appearance.
| Fence Type | Material Cost (per linear foot) | Average 100ft Project Material Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Basic Vinyl | $15-$18 | $1,500-$1,800 |
| Premium Vinyl | $20-$25 | $2,000-$2,500 |
| Basic Composite | $20-$25 | $2,000-$2,500 |
| Premium Composite | $30-$35 | $3,000-$3,500 |
Price variations within each category depend on factors such as panel height, style, texture, and color options. Premium products in both categories often feature enhanced UV protection, thicker materials, and more elaborate design options.
Installation Costs Comparison
Installation represents a significant portion of the total fencing project cost. Professional installation for vinyl fencing typically costs $5-$10 per linear foot, while composite fence installation ranges from $5-$12 per linear foot. The higher installation cost for composite reflects its greater weight and sometimes more complex assembly requirements.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Several factors influence installation costs for both materials:
- Ground conditions and terrain
- Fence height and style complexity
- Gate installations (add $250-$500 per gate)
- Removal of existing fencing (typically $3-$5 per linear foot)
- Regional labor rate differences
- Permit requirements (varies by municipality)
DIY installation is possible with both materials, potentially saving 30-40% on total project costs. However, improper installation can void warranties and lead to structural problems, so many homeowners opt for professional installation despite the higher upfront cost.
Best Brands for Composite Fences
Trex, TimberTech, and Fiberon stand out as industry leaders in the composite fencing market, known for their quality, warranty coverage, and product innovation. These manufacturers have established reputations for durability and aesthetic appeal.
Trex
Trex offers premium composite fencing with a 25-year warranty. Their Seclusions privacy fence line features realistic wood grain textures and comes in various earth-tone colors. Trex products typically cost $28-$38 per linear foot for materials and are known for exceptional fade and stain resistance.
TimberTech
TimberTech (AZEK) provides high-performance composite fencing with advanced protection against moisture and UV damage. Their FenceScape line offers a natural wood appearance with minimal maintenance requirements. TimberTech products generally range from $25-$35 per linear foot for materials.
Fiberon
Fiberon’s composite fencing features their patented PermaTech surface technology for enhanced durability. Their Good Life and ProTect Advantage lines offer various style options at price points from $22-$32 per linear foot for materials. Fiberon provides a 25-year warranty covering staining and fading.
Best Brands for Vinyl Fences
CertainTeed, Bufftech, and Freedom Outdoor Living lead the vinyl fencing industry, offering products with superior durability, design options, and warranty coverage compared to generic alternatives.
CertainTeed
CertainTeed’s Bufftech line features their exclusive CertaGrain texture that replicates natural wood grain. Their vinyl fencing includes proprietary ColorLast technology that provides fade protection, backed by a lifetime limited warranty. CertainTeed vinyl fencing materials typically cost $18-$28 per linear foot.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Freedom Outdoor Living
Freedom Outdoor Living offers vinyl fencing with SolarGuard technology for enhanced UV protection. Their products feature steel reinforcement for additional strength and come in various styles from privacy to decorative options. Materials typically cost $16-$25 per linear foot with a lifetime limited warranty.
Vinyl Fence Wholesaler
Popular among DIY installers, Vinyl Fence Wholesaler provides factory-direct pricing with material costs ranging from $15-$22 per linear foot. Their heavy-duty vinyl formulation includes UV inhibitors and impact modifiers. They offer a 30-year transferable warranty on most products.
Pros and Cons of Composite Fences
Understanding the advantages and limitations of composite fencing can help determine if it’s the right choice for your property needs.
Pros of Composite Fencing
- Natural wood appearance with realistic textures and color variations
- Exceptional durability with resistance to splitting, cracking, and warping
- Environmentally friendly, typically containing 40-95% recycled materials
- Minimal maintenance with no need for painting, staining, or sealing
- Available in various colors that maintain their appearance with minimal fading
- Resistant to insects, rot, and moisture damage
Cons of Composite Fencing
- Higher initial cost compared to vinyl and traditional wood options
- Heavier materials that may require stronger post supports
- Can experience some fading over time, particularly in intense sun exposure
- Limited color selection compared to painted wood options
- May develop mold or mildew in very humid environments without periodic cleaning
- More difficult to repair if damaged, often requiring panel replacement
Pros and Cons of Vinyl Fences
Vinyl fencing offers distinct advantages and limitations that differ from composite options.
Pros of Vinyl Fencing
- Virtually maintenance-free beyond occasional cleaning with water
- Lower initial cost compared to composite options
- Excellent longevity with warranties typically ranging from 20 years to lifetime
- Will not rot, splinter, or attract insects
- Resistant to graffiti and stains, which can be washed away
- Available in various styles and designs for different property needs
Cons of Vinyl Fencing
- Less natural appearance compared to wood or composite options
- Limited color options, primarily white, tan, and gray
- Can become brittle in extremely cold temperatures
- Lower-quality vinyl may yellow or become brittle over time
- Environmental concerns regarding PVC production and disposal
- More vulnerable to impact damage, especially in colder climates
Which Fence Type Is Right for You?
The choice between composite and vinyl fencing ultimately depends on your specific priorities and circumstances. Choose composite fencing if natural wood appearance and environmental sustainability are your top priorities and you’re willing to invest more upfront for these benefits. Composite offers the most realistic wood-like appearance while requiring minimal maintenance.
Vinyl fencing makes more sense if your primary concerns are minimal maintenance and lower initial cost. It’s particularly well-suited for clean, uniform designs and areas where appearance doesn’t need to mimic natural materials. Vinyl’s ease of cleaning also makes it ideal for areas prone to dirt, pollen, or mildew issues.
Climate considerations should influence your decision as well. Composite typically performs better in regions with extreme temperature fluctuations, while high-quality vinyl with appropriate impact modifiers performs exceptionally well in moderate climates. Both materials offer significant advantages over traditional wood in terms of longevity and maintenance requirements, making them sound long-term investments for property owners.