When it comes to exterior home renovation, siding selection stands as one of the most significant decisions homeowners face. Composite and vinyl siding represent two popular options in today’s market, each offering distinct characteristics and benefits. Composite siding generally costs $4-$12 per square foot installed while vinyl averages $2-$7, making vinyl the more budget-friendly option upfront. However, cost represents just one factor in this important decision. This comprehensive comparison examines material attributes, installation expenses, top manufacturers, and crucial advantages and disadvantages to help you determine which siding solution best meets your home’s needs.
Composite siding refers to engineered products manufactured from a combination of materials. Typically, it contains wood fibers, cement, and binding agents that create a durable exterior product. Most composite siding mimics the appearance of natural wood without the susceptibility to rot, warping, or insect damage. Common varieties include fiber cement, engineered wood, and wood-plastic composites.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
The manufacturing process involves compressing these materials under high pressure and temperature, creating panels with enhanced dimensional stability. This construction method results in a product that withstands environmental stresses better than traditional wood siding, while still offering aesthetic appeal. Composite products have gained popularity for their ability to combine the natural look of wood with improved performance characteristics.
What is Vinyl Siding?
Vinyl siding consists primarily of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a synthetic plastic polymer. As America’s most popular siding material, vinyl covers approximately 32% of new single-family homes according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s Survey of Construction. This lightweight material comes in various styles, textures, and colors designed to mimic wood and other traditional siding materials.
Manufactured through an extrusion process, vinyl siding panels are designed with interlocking edges for straightforward installation. Modern vinyl products often include insulation backing, improving energy efficiency and impact resistance. The material’s flexibility and resistance to moisture have contributed significantly to its widespread adoption across American homes in diverse climate zones.
Cost Comparison
Material Costs
The price difference between these siding options is substantial, with composite materials commanding a premium price point:
| Siding Type | Material Cost (per sq. ft.) |
|---|---|
| Composite (Fiber Cement) | $1.50-$5.00 |
| Composite (Engineered Wood) | $2.50-$5.50 |
| Vinyl (Standard) | $0.90-$2.50 |
| Vinyl (Premium/Insulated) | $2.50-$4.00 |
For an average 2,000 square foot home, vinyl siding materials might cost $1,800-$5,000, while composite materials could range from $3,000-$11,000. This significant difference makes vinyl the clear choice for budget-conscious homeowners. However, material costs represent only part of the total investment.
Installation Costs
Installation expenses vary considerably based on regional labor rates, project complexity, and siding type:
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
| Siding Type | Installation Cost (per sq. ft.) | Special Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Composite | $2.50-$7.00 | Requires specialized cutting tools, heavier materials |
| Vinyl | $1.50-$4.00 | Faster installation, lightweight materials |
Composite siding installation is typically more labor-intensive. Fiber cement siding is substantially heavier than vinyl, weighing approximately 2.5 pounds per square foot compared to vinyl’s 0.5 pounds, requiring additional labor and specialized cutting equipment. This weight difference often necessitates larger crews and extends project timelines, driving up labor costs.
Long-term Costs
While upfront expenses favor vinyl, long-term ownership costs may tell a different story. Composite siding typically lasts 30-50+ years with minimal maintenance, compared to vinyl’s 20-30 year lifespan. Over a 50-year period, a homeowner might replace vinyl siding once or twice, potentially making composite the more economical long-term choice despite higher initial costs.
Additionally, composite siding often carries longer warranties (some fiber cement products offer 50-year warranties) and may increase home resale values more significantly than vinyl. Insurance savings sometimes accompany composite installations due to their superior fire resistance, providing another long-term financial benefit.
Best Composite Siding Brands
Several manufacturers have established strong reputations in the composite siding market:
- James Hardie – The industry leader in fiber cement siding, holding approximately 90% market share in this category. Their HardiePlank lap siding offers exceptional durability with proprietary ColorPlus Technology for fade resistance.
- Nichiha – Known for architectural wall panels and fiber cement products with distinctive textures and finishes. Their products feature integrated rainscreen systems for enhanced moisture management.
- LP SmartSide – Produces engineered wood siding treated with zinc borate for termite and fungal decay resistance. Their products are significantly lighter than fiber cement while offering comparable durability.
- Allura – Manufactures fiber cement siding with wood grain textures and pre-finished color options. Their products feature high impact resistance and fire-retardant properties.
These manufacturers typically offer comprehensive warranties ranging from 25-50 years, reflecting confidence in their products’ longevity and performance capabilities across various climate conditions.
Best Vinyl Siding Brands
The vinyl siding market features several established manufacturers known for quality and innovation:
- CertainTeed – Offers premium vinyl siding with their Monogram and Cedar Impressions lines, featuring authentic wood textures and industry-leading color retention technology.
- Royal Building Products – Known for their Celect cellular PVC siding that mimics the appearance of wood while offering superior insulation properties.
- Mastic by Ply Gem – Produces vinyl siding with their proprietary SolarDefense Reflective Technology, designed to maintain color integrity even in extreme temperatures.
- Alside – Manufactures insulated vinyl siding products that improve energy efficiency while providing enhanced impact resistance.
Most premium vinyl manufacturers provide limited lifetime warranties on their products, though coverage for color fading typically extends only 5-10 years. Higher-end vinyl products often incorporate UV inhibitors and impact modifiers to enhance durability and appearance longevity.
Pros and Cons
Composite Siding Advantages & Disadvantages
Composite siding offers numerous benefits that justify its higher price point:
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
- Superior durability – Resistant to rot, termites, and severe weather conditions
- Excellent fire resistance – Fiber cement products are non-combustible
- Dimensional stability – Minimal expansion/contraction with temperature changes
- Authentic appearance – More realistic wood-grain textures
- Paintable surface – Can be repainted multiple times for color changes
- Environmental resistance – Withstands UV exposure without significant fading
However, composite siding does present certain drawbacks:
- Higher initial cost – Significantly more expensive than vinyl
- Weight considerations – May require structural reinforcement for some applications
- Installation complexity – Requires specialized tools and skilled labor
- Limited DIY potential – Not recommended for amateur installation
Vinyl Siding Advantages & Disadvantages
Vinyl siding maintains popularity for several compelling reasons:
- Cost-effectiveness – Most affordable siding option upfront
- Low maintenance – Requires only occasional cleaning
- Easy installation – Lightweight and designed for straightforward application
- Color variety – Available in hundreds of factory-applied colors
- DIY potential – Accessible for moderately skilled homeowners
- Insulation options – Available with integrated foam backing for energy efficiency
Notable disadvantages include:
- Susceptibility to damage – Can crack in cold weather or during impacts
- Environmental concerns – PVC production and disposal raise sustainability issues
- Temperature sensitivity – Expands and contracts substantially with temperature fluctuations
- Cannot be painted – Color changes require replacement
- Lower perceived value – May not enhance home resale value as significantly as other materials
Durability and Maintenance
Composite siding generally outperforms vinyl in durability tests, with fiber cement products showing particular resistance to impacts, moisture, and UV radiation. While vinyl might dent or crack under significant impact, composite materials typically withstand these challenges better. In extreme weather conditions like hailstorms, the performance difference becomes especially apparent.
Maintenance requirements differ substantially between these materials. Vinyl primarily needs occasional washing with soap and water to maintain appearance. Composite siding may require repainting every 7-15 years depending on the manufacturer and finish quality. Some fiber cement manufacturers now offer factory-applied finishes warranted against fading for up to 15 years, reducing this maintenance burden.
Environmental Considerations
The environmental impact of siding choices extends beyond their manufacturing processes to include durability and end-of-life disposal. Vinyl siding’s production involves potentially harmful chemicals, but its long lifespan and minimal maintenance requirements partially offset these concerns by reducing replacement frequency and chemical use during ownership.
Composite siding, particularly fiber cement, requires significant energy during manufacturing but contains primarily natural materials. Many engineered wood composites incorporate recycled content and sustainable wood fibers. At disposal, composite materials generally present fewer environmental concerns than vinyl, which may release harmful compounds if incinerated. Some manufacturers now offer take-back programs for composite materials, further reducing environmental impact.
Which is Better for Your Home?
The ideal siding choice ultimately depends on several factors specific to your situation:
- Budget constraints – For tight budgets, vinyl offers the most affordable solution
- Climate conditions – Extreme temperature fluctuations or high humidity favor composite materials
- Architectural style – Historic or premium homes often benefit from composite’s authentic appearance
- Planned ownership duration – Longer ownership periods justify composite’s higher initial investment
- HOA requirements – Some associations restrict certain siding materials or colors
For homeowners prioritizing long-term value and performance, composite siding generally offers superior results despite higher upfront costs. Those needing immediate curb appeal improvement at minimal expense will find vinyl siding provides satisfactory performance in most applications. Consider consulting with multiple contractors to obtain detailed quotes specific to your home’s requirements before making this significant investment decision.