When considering a new roof for your home, metal and tile roofing represent two popular high-performance options with distinct characteristics. Both materials offer durability far exceeding asphalt shingles, but differ significantly in aesthetics, weight, cost, and performance profiles. Metal roofing typically costs $8-$14 per square foot installed, while concrete tiles range from $10-$15 and clay tiles from $15-$25 per square foot installed. Your choice should balance initial investment against long-term durability, maintenance requirements, climate suitability, and aesthetic preferences. This comparison will help you determine which roofing material best meets your specific needs.
Metal roofing has evolved significantly from its utilitarian origins to become a versatile and attractive option for residential applications. Modern metal roofs come in various materials including steel, aluminum, copper, and zinc alloys, each offering different price points and performance characteristics. The most common styles include standing seam panels, metal shingles, and stone-coated metal tiles that mimic traditional roofing materials.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Steel roofing, the most widely used metal roofing material, typically undergoes galvanization and coating with zinc or a zinc-aluminum alloy to prevent rust. Aluminum roofing, while more expensive, offers superior corrosion resistance, making it ideal for coastal areas. Premium options like copper and zinc develop attractive patinas over time and can last a century or more with proper maintenance.
Metal roofing systems can be installed over existing roofs in some cases, reducing tear-off costs and landfill waste. They typically weigh between 50-150 pounds per square (100 square feet), making them suitable for most structural systems without additional reinforcement.
Overview of Tile Roofing
Tile roofing primarily comes in two varieties: clay and concrete, with each offering distinctive aesthetics and performance characteristics. Clay tiles, created from natural earth clays formed and fired at high temperatures, deliver the classic terracotta look associated with Mediterranean, Spanish, and southwestern architectural styles. Concrete tiles, made from a mixture of sand, cement, and water, offer more color options and typically cost less than clay alternatives.
Both types provide exceptional durability with expected lifespans of 50+ years for concrete and 100+ years for clay when properly installed and maintained. Their distinctive profiles create natural ventilation channels beneath the tiles, improving energy efficiency by reducing heat transfer into attic spaces.
Tile roofing represents one of the heaviest roofing options, weighing between 850-950 pounds per square for clay tiles and 550-750 pounds per square for concrete tiles. This substantial weight often necessitates structural engineering assessment and possibly reinforcement before installation, particularly when replacing lighter roofing materials.
Price Comparison: Material Costs
Metal roofing materials typically range from $4-$12 per square foot depending on the metal type, thickness (gauge), and finish quality. Standard corrugated steel panels represent the most economical option at $4-$5 per square foot, while aluminum shingles generally cost $5-$9 per square foot. Premium materials command higher prices: copper averages $14-$22 per square foot, and zinc falls in the $13-$18 range.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
For tile roofing, concrete tiles typically cost $3-$5 per square foot for the materials alone, while clay tiles range from $7-$10 per square foot. Premium hand-made clay tiles or specialized shapes can reach $15-$20 per square foot. Additional components like underlayment, flashing, and ridge caps add to the total material expenses.
| Roofing Type | Material Cost (per sq. ft.) | Total Installed Cost (per sq. ft.) |
|---|---|---|
| Steel Panels | $4-$5 | $8-$10 |
| Aluminum Shingles | $5-$9 | $9-$14 |
| Copper | $14-$22 | $18-$28 |
| Concrete Tiles | $3-$5 | $10-$15 |
| Clay Tiles | $7-$10 | $15-$25 |
Installation Cost Analysis
Installation costs often exceed material expenses for both metal and tile roofing, with tile installation generally commanding higher labor rates due to its weight, complexity, and specialized skills required. Metal roof installation typically adds $4-$6 per square foot to material costs, while tile installation can add $7-$15 per square foot depending on tile type and roof complexity.
Factors affecting installation costs include roof pitch, accessibility, existing roof removal, structural reinforcement needs, and regional labor rates. Complex roofs with multiple valleys, dormers, skylights, or chimneys increase installation time and costs for both materials.
Tile roofing often requires structural assessment and possibly reinforcement, adding $1,000-$10,000 to overall project costs. Metal roofing generally doesn’t require structural modifications unless the existing structure is compromised. For an average 2,000 square foot roof, total installation costs typically range from $16,000-$28,000 for metal and $20,000-$50,000 for tile.
Durability and Lifespan
Both metal and tile roofing systems offer exceptional longevity compared to conventional asphalt shingles, which typically last 15-25 years. Quality metal roofs generally last 40-70 years, with premium materials like copper and zinc potentially lasting a century or more. Steel roofs with proper galvanization and coating typically provide 40-60 years of service, while aluminum may last 50+ years, particularly in coastal environments.
Tile roofs demonstrate even greater longevity potential. Concrete tiles typically last 50+ years, while clay tiles are renowned for their century-plus lifespan. The Mediterranean region features many buildings with clay tile roofs that have remained intact for several centuries, highlighting their exceptional durability.
Environmental factors significantly impact lifespan for both materials. Metal roofs perform excellently in most climates but may dent under extreme hail. Tile roofs excel in hot regions but can crack in freeze-thaw cycles. Both systems’ longevity depends heavily on proper installation, underlayment quality, and maintenance practices.
Maintenance Requirements
Metal roofing typically requires minimal maintenance, primarily consisting of periodic inspections, debris removal, and occasional washing to prevent dirt buildup and maintain reflectivity. Annual checks should focus on fasteners, seams, and flashing to ensure system integrity. Scratches in protective coatings should be promptly touched up to prevent corrosion.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Tile roofing needs somewhat more attentive maintenance, particularly regarding cracked or broken tiles, which should be replaced promptly to maintain water-shedding capability. The underlayment, typically lasting 20-30 years (less than the tiles themselves), often requires replacement while the original tiles remain serviceable. Regular cleaning prevents debris accumulation in valleys and gutters, while moss and algae management may be necessary in humid climates.
Both roofing types benefit from professional inspections every 2-3 years to identify and address minor issues before they compromise system integrity. Proper maintenance extends service life and helps preserve manufacturer warranties, which typically run 30-50 years for both materials.
Top Brands for Metal Roofing
Several manufacturers have established reputations for quality metal roofing products backed by robust warranties and dealer networks. Leading brands include:
- Metal Sales Manufacturing Corporation: Offering a comprehensive range of metal roofing products with 50-year warranties, strong color options, and national distribution.
- McElroy Metal: Known for high-quality standing seam systems and metal shingles with excellent technical support and a 45-year paint warranty on many products.
- ATAS International: Specializes in architectural metal roofing with distinctive profiles, premium finishes, and sustainable options including solar integration.
- Englert Inc.: Recognized for on-site roll forming capabilities, reducing seams and enhancing weather resistance with warranties up to 35 years.
- Classic Metal Roofing Systems: Focuses on aluminum shingles that replicate traditional roofing materials with lifetime transferable warranties.
Each manufacturer offers distinct advantages in terms of product range, warranty protection, and specialized applications. Consulting with experienced contractors familiar with these brands can help determine which product line best suits your specific needs.
Top Brands for Tile Roofing
The tile roofing market features several established manufacturers known for quality products with exceptional longevity and aesthetic appeal. Industry leaders include:
- Boral Roofing: America’s largest tile manufacturer offering concrete and clay options with innovative cool roof technology and substantial warranties up to 50 years.
- Eagle Roofing Products: Specializes in concrete roof tiles with enhanced durability and comprehensive style options that replicate various traditional roofing materials.
- Ludowici: Premium American manufacturer creating distinctive terra cotta tiles since 1888, with the industry’s longest warranty (75 years) and custom capabilities.
- MCA Clay Roof Tile: Offers hand-crafted Mediterranean-style clay tiles with authentic styling and traditional manufacturing techniques.
- Vande Hey Raleigh: Creates custom concrete tiles with unique profiles, textures, and colors for distinctive architectural applications.
When selecting a tile manufacturer, consider factors beyond price including color consistency, freeze-thaw testing data, warranty terms, and local installation expertise. Regional manufacturers may offer advantages in certain markets with styles specifically suited to local architectural traditions.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing
Advantages
Metal roofing offers impressive performance advantages including lightweight construction, fire resistance, and exceptional weather resilience. Its reflective surface can reduce cooling costs by 10-25% in warm climates. With recycled content often exceeding 25% and being 100% recyclable at end-of-life, metal represents an environmentally responsible choice.
Installation timelines for metal roofing are typically 2-3 times faster than tile installation, reducing labor costs and minimizing exposure to weather during the construction process. Many systems can be installed over existing roofing, eliminating tear-off expenses and landfill impact.
Disadvantages
Potential drawbacks include higher initial cost compared to asphalt shingles, though lower than many tile options. Some metal roofing, particularly lower-gauge steel panels, may be susceptible to denting from severe hail or falling branches. Improper installation can lead to oil canning (waviness in flat panels) or fastener issues.
Noise concerns during rain or hail can be effectively addressed through proper installation with solid decking and insulation. Color matching for future repairs may present challenges as metal finishes can fade gradually over decades of sun exposure.
Pros and Cons of Tile Roofing
Advantages
Tile roofing delivers unmatched aesthetic appeal with traditional styling that enhances architectural authenticity for many home styles. Its exceptional durability translates to the lowest lifetime cost when amortized over its full service life. The natural thermal mass of tiles helps regulate temperature fluctuations, potentially reducing energy costs.
Individual tiles can be replaced when damaged without compromising the entire system. Many manufacturers offer Class A fire ratings and warranties against manufacturing defects for 50+ years. Concrete tiles are available with specialized coatings that reflect solar energy, improving energy efficiency in hot climates.
Disadvantages
The substantial weight of tile roofing represents its primary disadvantage, often requiring structural assessment and possibly reinforcement. Higher initial cost compared to conventional roofing materials presents a significant upfront investment, though long-term value remains excellent. Installation complexity demands specialized expertise, limiting contractor options in some markets.
Tiles can crack when subjected to point impacts or when walked upon incorrectly during maintenance. In freeze-thaw environments, water absorption in some concrete tiles may lead to cracking or spalling without proper manufacturing techniques and installation. These issues can be minimized by selecting high-quality tiles appropriate for local climate conditions.
Environmental Considerations
Both metal and tile roofing offer significant environmental advantages compared to petroleum-based asphalt shingles, particularly regarding longevity and end-of-life scenarios. Metal roofing contains recycled content (typically 25-95% depending on material) and remains 100% recyclable after its service life. This closed-loop potential significantly reduces environmental impact.
Tile roofing’s primary environmental benefit stems from its exceptional longevity, reducing manufacturing and replacement frequency. Clay tiles utilize natural materials with minimal processing beyond firing, while concrete tiles incorporate abundant materials with moderate energy inputs. Both types can be crushed for use as aggregate at end-of-life, though recycling infrastructure varies by region.
Energy efficiency varies by climate and specific product. In hot climates, both materials can be configured with heat-reflective properties that earn ENERGY STAR certification and potentially qualify for utility incentives or tax credits. The thermal mass of tile provides additional benefits in regions with significant day-night temperature variations.
Which Roof Type Is Right For Your Home?
Your optimal roofing choice depends on several factors including architectural style, climate conditions, budget constraints, and long-term plans. Metal roofing typically represents the better choice for modern or contemporary homes, lighter structural systems, DIY-oriented homeowners, or regions with extreme weather variations. Its lower weight, faster installation, and moderate cost position it as the more practical option for many situations.
Tile roofing generally proves ideal for Mediterranean, Spanish, Mission, Southwestern, or European-inspired architectural styles where historical authenticity matters. Its premium aesthetics and exceptional longevity make it appropriate for “forever homes” where the higher initial investment can be amortized over decades of ownership. Homes with robust structural systems or in consistently warm climates particularly benefit from tile’s characteristics.
The final decision should balance immediate budget realities against long-term performance requirements and aesthetic preferences. Consulting with qualified roofing professionals who have experience with both materials can provide valuable insights specific to your property’s unique characteristics and local climate considerations.