When it comes to exterior home siding, homeowners often find themselves choosing between traditional clapboard and modern vinyl options. Both materials offer distinct advantages in terms of aesthetics, durability, maintenance requirements, and cost considerations. Clapboard siding provides classic appeal and potential longevity, while vinyl siding offers affordability and minimal upkeep. This comparison examines the crucial factors that influence decision-making between these popular siding materials, including material and installation costs, leading manufacturers, and the inherent strengths and limitations of each option to help homeowners make informed choices for their exterior renovation projects.
Clapboard siding, also known as lap siding or weatherboard, is a traditional exterior covering consisting of horizontal wooden boards that overlap slightly. This classic siding style has adorned American homes for centuries, dating back to colonial architecture. The overlapping design effectively channels water away from the house, providing both protection and distinctive shadow lines that create visual appeal.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
What is Clapboard Siding?
Traditional clapboard consists of wooden boards installed horizontally with each board overlapping the one below it. The boards are typically tapered, being thicker along the bottom edge and thinner at the top. Wood clapboard is most commonly made from cedar, pine, spruce, or redwood, though modern variations include fiber cement and engineered wood products that mimic the appearance of traditional wooden clapboard while offering improved performance characteristics.
Types of Clapboard
- Traditional Wood Clapboard – Natural cedar, pine, redwood or cypress boards
- Fiber Cement Clapboard – Composite material made from cement, sand, and cellulose fibers
- Engineered Wood Clapboard – Manufactured from wood fibers bonded with resins
- Hardiplank – James Hardie’s proprietary fiber cement clapboard product
Each clapboard variation offers different benefits in terms of price, durability, and maintenance requirements. Wood provides authentic character but requires more maintenance, while fiber cement offers excellent durability with less upkeep but at a higher initial cost.
Understanding Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding emerged in the 1950s as an affordable alternative to aluminum siding and has since become America’s most popular exterior cladding material. Made primarily from polyvinyl chloride (PVC), vinyl siding accounts for approximately 30% of new home exterior finishes in the United States. Its popularity stems from its combination of affordability, low maintenance requirements, and diverse style options.
What is Vinyl Siding?
Vinyl siding consists of PVC panels manufactured to mimic traditional wood siding styles. The material contains UV inhibitors to prevent sun damage and impact modifiers to enhance durability. Modern manufacturing techniques have significantly improved vinyl’s performance characteristics over earlier generations. Today’s premium vinyl siding can withstand winds up to 110 mph and extreme temperature fluctuations while maintaining its appearance.
Types of Vinyl Siding
- Traditional Lap/Clapboard Style – Horizontal panels that mimic wooden clapboard
- Dutch Lap – Features a decorative groove in each panel
- Vertical Siding – Board and batten or vertical panel styles
- Insulated Vinyl Siding – Includes rigid foam backing for improved energy efficiency
- Shake and Shingle – Mimics the appearance of cedar shakes
Vinyl siding comes in numerous colors, textures, and profiles to suit various architectural styles. Premium lines offer enhanced thickness (measured in mils), improved color retention, and more realistic wood grain textures.
Price Comparison
Material costs vary significantly between clapboard and vinyl siding options, with several factors influencing the final price including material quality, brand, and regional market variations. Generally, vinyl siding represents the more economical choice initially, while certain types of clapboard command premium prices but may offer longer lifespans.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Clapboard Siding Costs
| Clapboard Type | Price per Square Foot | Average Cost (2,000 sq ft home) |
|---|---|---|
| Pine/Spruce Clapboard | $5-$8 | $10,000-$16,000 |
| Cedar Clapboard | $6-$12 | $12,000-$24,000 |
| Fiber Cement Clapboard | $5-$13 | $10,000-$26,000 |
| Engineered Wood Clapboard | $4-$9 | $8,000-$18,000 |
Premium cedar or redwood clapboard represents the highest material cost, while pine offers a more economical wood option. Fiber cement products like James Hardie siding fall in the middle to upper range but provide exceptional durability. These prices reflect material costs only and don’t include installation, painting, or finishing.
Vinyl Siding Costs
| Vinyl Siding Type | Price per Square Foot | Average Cost (2,000 sq ft home) |
|---|---|---|
| Economy Vinyl (0.040″ thickness) | $3-$5 | $6,000-$10,000 |
| Standard Vinyl (0.044″ thickness) | $4-$6 | $8,000-$12,000 |
| Premium Vinyl (0.046″+ thickness) | $5-$7 | $10,000-$14,000 |
| Insulated Vinyl Siding | $6-$10 | $12,000-$20,000 |
Vinyl siding thickness, measured in mils (thousandths of an inch), significantly impacts price and quality, with thicker products offering better durability and impact resistance. Insulated vinyl siding, while more expensive, provides energy efficiency benefits that can offset costs through reduced heating and cooling expenses.
Installation Costs
Installation represents a significant portion of the total project cost for both siding types. Labor expenses can sometimes exceed material costs, particularly with more labor-intensive clapboard installation. Several factors influence installation costs, including home height, accessibility, removal of existing siding, and regional labor rates.
Clapboard Installation
Professional clapboard installation typically costs between $4-$8 per square foot in labor alone. The installation process is more labor-intensive and time-consuming than vinyl siding, requiring precise measurements, cutting, and placement. Additional expenses include painting (approximately $1-$3 per square foot), trim work, and waterproofing. Preparation work, such as removing old siding or addressing structural issues, will add to the total cost.
Fiber cement clapboard installation tends to be on the higher end of this range due to the specialized skills and equipment required to work with this heavier material. Many manufacturers require certified installers for warranty validation.
Vinyl Installation
Vinyl siding installation labor typically ranges from $2.50-$4.50 per square foot. The installation process is generally faster and more straightforward than clapboard, with specialized tools allowing for efficient installation. Vinyl requires no painting or finishing, which reduces both initial installation time and long-term maintenance costs.
Complex architectural features, multiple stories, or difficult access points will increase installation costs for both siding types. Insulated vinyl siding may command slightly higher installation rates due to the additional weight and specialized installation requirements.
Best Brands
Quality varies significantly between manufacturers, with established brands generally offering superior products, more extensive warranties, and better customer support. Investing in reputable brands typically results in better long-term performance and appearance, though premium brands command higher prices.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Top Clapboard Manufacturers
- James Hardie – Industry leader in fiber cement clapboard, known for durability and authentic appearance
- Allura – Premium fiber cement products with excellent warranty coverage
- LP SmartSide – Engineered wood clapboard with advanced technology for moisture resistance
- Maibec – Specializes in premium cedar clapboard with factory-applied finishes
- CertainTeed – Offers fiber cement clapboard with extensive color options
James Hardie stands out with its climate-specific product lines engineered for different regional conditions. Their ColorPlus Technology provides factory-applied finishes with superior color retention. Fiber cement products generally carry 30-50 year warranties, while natural wood products typically offer shorter warranty periods.
Leading Vinyl Siding Brands
- CertainTeed – Premium vinyl siding with extensive color options and textures
- Royal Building Products – Known for innovative designs and cedar-like textures
- Ply Gem – Wide range of vinyl products across price points
- Alside – Offers energy-efficient insulated vinyl siding
- Mastic by Ply Gem – Known for durability and color retention
CertainTeed’s Monogram and Cedar Impressions lines are considered among the highest quality vinyl siding products available. Leading manufacturers typically offer lifetime limited warranties on vinyl siding, often including protection against fading, cracking, and other common issues.
Pros and Cons
Both clapboard and vinyl siding offer distinct advantages and disadvantages that should be carefully considered based on your specific needs, budget, and aesthetic preferences.
Clapboard Advantages and Disadvantages
Clapboard Pros:
- Authentic, classic appearance with natural visual depth
- Can increase home value, especially in historic neighborhoods
- Wood and fiber cement are environmentally sustainable options
- Can be repaired in sections rather than requiring full replacement
- Fiber cement offers excellent fire resistance
- Premium clapboard can last 50+ years with proper maintenance
Clapboard Cons:
- Higher initial investment than vinyl
- Requires regular maintenance (painting every 5-10 years)
- Wood versions are susceptible to rot, insects, and moisture damage
- Installation is more labor-intensive and costly
- Fiber cement is heavy and requires specialized installation
- Less energy efficient unless additional insulation is added
Vinyl Advantages and Disadvantages
Vinyl Pros:
- Most affordable siding option upfront
- Minimal maintenance requirements (occasional cleaning)
- Available in hundreds of colors and styles
- Doesn’t require painting or finishing
- Resistant to insects and moisture
- Insulated options improve energy efficiency
- Typically includes lengthy manufacturer warranties
Vinyl Cons:
- Less authentic appearance than real wood
- Can crack or warp in extreme temperatures
- Difficult to repair individual sections without visible differences
- Not environmentally friendly (petroleum-based product)
- Color can fade over time, especially with darker shades
- May reduce home value in historic or upscale neighborhoods
- Typically shorter lifespan than premium clapboard options
Which is Better for Your Home?
The ideal siding choice depends on several factors specific to your situation and preferences. Consider your budget, home’s architectural style, local climate, neighborhood standards, and how long you plan to stay in your home when making this significant investment decision.
Clapboard siding may be the better choice if you own a historic home, live in an upscale neighborhood where traditional materials are valued, plan to stay in your home long-term, or prioritize authentic appearance and potential resale value. The higher initial investment can pay dividends in aesthetic appeal and longevity.
Vinyl siding offers advantages for homeowners seeking affordability, minimal maintenance, energy efficiency through insulated options, or those in regions with extreme weather conditions. Modern premium vinyl products have significantly improved in appearance and durability, making them viable options even for discerning homeowners.
Consider consulting with several qualified contractors to obtain detailed estimates and product recommendations based on your specific home requirements and regional climate conditions. This investment in research will help ensure satisfaction with your final siding decision for years to come.