When renovating a bathroom, choosing between a tile or acrylic shower is a significant decision that impacts both aesthetics and budget. Tile showers offer customization and luxury appeal but require more maintenance and higher installation costs, typically ranging from $1,000-$10,000+ depending on materials and complexity. In contrast, acrylic showers provide affordability and easier installation at $700-$5,000, with simplified maintenance but fewer custom options. This comprehensive comparison explores the costs, installation processes, top manufacturers, and essential pros and cons to help you determine which shower solution aligns with your needs, preferences, and budget constraints.
Tile showers represent a traditional and highly customizable bathroom option that has stood the test of time. These installations consist of individual tiles adhered to a waterproof substrate, typically with grout filling the spaces between tiles. The finished result creates a waterproof enclosure that can be designed to virtually any specification.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Available materials include ceramic, porcelain, natural stone (marble, granite, slate), glass, and even metal tiles. Each material offers different aesthetics, durability levels, and price points. Porcelain tiles remain particularly popular due to their excellent water resistance and durability, with ceramic providing a more budget-friendly alternative.
The appeal of tile showers largely stems from their design flexibility. Homeowners can select from countless colors, patterns, textures, and layouts to create truly unique shower spaces. From subway tile arrangements to intricate mosaics, the creative possibilities are nearly limitless.
Understanding Acrylic Showers
Acrylic showers represent a modern alternative to traditional tile installations. These shower units are manufactured from sheets of acrylic material that has been heated, formed into shower shapes, and reinforced with fiberglass for additional structural integrity. The result is a single-piece or multi-piece shower system that arrives ready to install.
Unlike tile showers that are built piece by piece on-site, acrylic showers come in prefabricated forms that include the shower pan, walls, and sometimes additional features like built-in shelving, seats, or grab bars. They’re available in standard sizes and configurations, though some manufacturers offer semi-custom options.
The manufacturing process allows acrylic showers to mimic more expensive materials, including the look of tile, stone, or marble, without the associated costs or maintenance requirements. Modern manufacturing techniques have significantly improved the aesthetic options compared to older plastic shower units.
Cost Comparison: Materials and Overall Expense
Tile Shower Costs
Tile material costs vary dramatically based on the type selected, ranging from $0.50 per square foot for basic ceramic options to $15+ per square foot for premium natural stone or designer tiles. For a standard shower enclosure of approximately 32 square feet, basic tile materials might cost $300-$500, while premium options could exceed $2,000 for materials alone.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Beyond the tiles themselves, additional materials include backer board ($30-$50 per sheet), waterproofing membrane ($100-$300), mortar, grout, and sealer ($100-$200). A shower pan or liner adds $100-$500 depending on whether it’s prefabricated or custom-built.
All told, materials for a tile shower typically range from $1,000-$4,000 before installation costs, with premium custom designs potentially exceeding $10,000 in materials alone.
Acrylic Shower Costs
Basic acrylic shower kits start around $300-$600 for standard alcove units, with mid-range options between $600-$1,500. Premium acrylic systems with advanced features like integrated storage, seating, or therapeutic jets can cost $1,500-$3,000+.
Additional materials required for installation include plumbing supplies, adhesives, and sealing materials, typically adding $100-$300 to the project. Unlike tile showers, acrylic units don’t require separate waterproofing systems, backer boards, or grout.
The total material cost for an acrylic shower installation typically falls between $400-$3,300, with most standard projects landing in the $700-$1,800 range. This represents a significant savings compared to mid-range and premium tile installations.
Installation Process and Labor Costs
Tile Shower Installation
Installing a tile shower is a labor-intensive, multi-step process that typically requires professional expertise. The installation includes preparing the subfloor, installing the shower pan, waterproofing, installing backer board, setting tiles, grouting, and sealing. A professional tile shower installation typically takes 3-7 days to complete, depending on complexity.
Labor costs for professional tile shower installation range from $1,000-$5,000+, with the national average falling around $2,500. Custom designs, intricate patterns, or special tile types can increase labor costs significantly.
When combined with materials, a professionally installed tile shower typically costs between $2,000-$10,000, with luxury custom installations potentially exceeding $15,000. DIY installation remains possible but challenging for inexperienced homeowners and requires specialized tools and knowledge.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Acrylic Shower Installation
Acrylic shower installation offers a significantly faster and simpler process. Professional installation typically takes 1-2 days, as the prefabricated unit requires minimal on-site assembly. The process includes removal of the old shower, preparation of the installation space, positioning of the acrylic unit, and connection of plumbing fixtures.
Professional installation costs for acrylic showers range from $300-$1,500, depending on the complexity of the unit and whether any plumbing modifications are required. Many acrylic showers are designed specifically for DIY installation, making this a more accessible option for homeowners with basic skills.
The total cost for a professionally installed acrylic shower system typically falls between $700-$5,000, with most standard installations in the $1,200-$3,000 range. This represents a cost savings of approximately 40-60% compared to comparable tile shower installations.
Best Brands and Manufacturers
Top Tile Brands
Daltile stands as the largest ceramic tile manufacturer in the U.S., offering extensive lines of porcelain, ceramic, and natural stone tiles at various price points. Their products are widely available through home improvement stores and specialty retailers, with prices ranging from $2-$15 per square foot.
For luxury installations, Ann Sacks offers designer tile collections featuring unique patterns, artisanal craftsmanship, and premium materials. Their prices typically range from $20-$100+ per square foot, catering to high-end renovations.
Other reputable tile manufacturers include American Olean, Florida Tile, Marazzi, and Porcelanosa. Budget-conscious consumers often turn to MSI and Emser Tile, which offer quality options at competitive price points between $1-$8 per square foot.
Leading Acrylic Shower Manufacturers
Kohler stands as a premium acrylic shower manufacturer, offering high-quality units with innovative features and sleek designs. Their LuxStone shower systems represent a hybrid approach, with engineered stone surfaces that mimic the appearance of natural materials. Kohler units typically range from $1,000-$4,000.
American Standard provides reliable mid-range acrylic shower solutions with good warranties and nationwide availability. Their products are known for durability and practical designs, with prices typically between $500-$2,000.
Other notable acrylic shower manufacturers include Delta, Sterling (a Kohler company), Aquatic, Swan, and Aker. Budget-conscious shoppers often choose Mustee or ASB shower units, available at major home improvement stores for $300-$800.
Pros and Cons of Tile Showers
Advantages of Tile Showers
- Unlimited design flexibility with countless tile options, patterns, and layouts
- Premium aesthetic appeal that often increases home value
- Ability to create custom sizes and configurations for unusual spaces
- Excellent durability with properly installed ceramic or porcelain tile potentially lasting 20+ years
- Damaged individual tiles can be replaced without removing the entire shower
- Higher-end appearance that appeals to luxury homebuyers
Disadvantages of Tile Showers
- Grout lines require regular cleaning and periodic resealing to prevent mold, mildew, and water penetration
- Higher material and installation costs compared to acrylic options
- Installation requires specialized skills and takes significantly longer
- Potential for leaks if waterproofing is improperly installed
- Harder surface can be uncomfortable for elderly or those with mobility issues
- Cold surface temperature unless paired with radiant heating systems
Pros and Cons of Acrylic Showers
Advantages of Acrylic Showers
- Lower overall cost for both materials and installation
- Significantly faster installation process, typically completed in 1-2 days
- Minimal maintenance with no grout lines to clean or reseal
- Non-porous surface naturally resists mold and mildew
- Warmer surface temperature than tile, providing greater comfort
- Factory waterproofing reduces the risk of leaks compared to site-built shower systems
- Many models offer integrated features like seats, shelving, and grab bars
Disadvantages of Acrylic Showers
- Limited customization options with predetermined sizes and configurations
- Less prestigious appearance compared to custom tile work
- Can develop yellowing over time, particularly with lower-quality acrylic
- Susceptible to scratches and potential cracking under heavy impact
- Typically shorter lifespan (10-15 years) compared to high-quality tile installations
- Limited repair options if damagedâoften requires complete replacement
Which Option Is Right For Your Bathroom?
Choose a tile shower if you prioritize customization, luxury aesthetics, and long-term durability despite higher costs and maintenance requirements. Tile showers make particular sense for high-end homes, where the investment can be recouped in property value, or for uniquely shaped spaces requiring custom solutions.
Opt for an acrylic shower if budget, installation speed, and low maintenance are your primary concerns. These systems offer practical, cost-effective solutions that work well for rental properties, secondary bathrooms, or situations where a faster renovation timeline is necessary.
Consider your household’s specific needs as well. Homes with elderly residents might benefit from acrylic’s warmer surface and the ease of adding integrated accessibility features. Design-focused homeowners may find the creative possibilities of tile more appealing despite the additional investment required.
Ultimately, the decision between tile and acrylic comes down to balancing your budget constraints, aesthetic preferences, maintenance willingness, and long-term plans for the property. Both options can provide functional, attractive shower solutions when properly selected and installed.