When it comes to flooring options, carpet and laminate represent two popular yet distinctly different choices for homeowners. Carpet offers warmth and comfort underfoot with sound-dampening qualities, while laminate provides durability and easy maintenance with wood-like aesthetics. The decision between these flooring types ultimately depends on your budget, lifestyle needs, and the specific rooms being renovated. This article breaks down the critical factors to considerâincluding material costs, installation expenses, leading manufacturers, and the advantages and disadvantages of each optionâto help you make an informed flooring decision for your home improvement project.
The cost difference between carpet and laminate can be significant depending on the quality and style you choose. On average, carpet costs between $2 and $7 per square foot for materials alone, with budget options starting around $1 per square foot and premium wool carpets reaching up to $20 per square foot.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Laminate flooring typically ranges from $1 to $5 per square foot for materials. Higher-end laminate with enhanced durability features and more realistic wood appearances can cost between $5 and $8 per square foot. Generally, laminate offers more consistency in pricing across different styles compared to carpet.
| Flooring Type | Budget Price/sq ft | Mid-Range Price/sq ft | Premium Price/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carpet | $1-$2 | $3-$5 | $6-$20 |
| Laminate | $1-$2 | $2-$4 | $5-$8 |
Additional cost factors include carpet padding ($.30-$1 per square foot) and laminate underlayment ($.30-$.80 per square foot), which are essential components for proper installation of each respective flooring type.
Installation Costs: What to Expect
Installation expenses can significantly impact your total project budget. Professional carpet installation typically costs between $1 and $3 per square foot, bringing the total installed cost of carpet to approximately $3-$10 per square foot including materials.
For laminate flooring, professional installation ranges from $2 to $5 per square foot, depending on the complexity of the room layout and any necessary subfloor preparation. The total installed cost for laminate flooring generally falls between $3 and $13 per square foot.
DIY installation presents different considerations for each flooring type. Laminate offers relatively straightforward installation with click-lock systems that many homeowners can manage, potentially saving $2-$5 per square foot in labor costs. Carpet installation requires specialized tools like stretchers and knee kickers, making it more challenging for DIY projects and usually more cost-effective to hire professionals.
Top Brands for Carpet Flooring
Mohawk
Mohawk Industries stands as one of the largest flooring manufacturers worldwide, offering extensive carpet options from budget to premium lines. They’re known for their SmartStrand technology, which features built-in stain resistance and exceptional durability. Price range: $2-$12 per square foot.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Shaw Floors
Shaw Floors provides high-quality carpet products with innovative features like R2X stain and soil resistance technology. Their LifeGuard waterproof backing system offers superior moisture protection compared to traditional carpet backing. Price range: $3-$10 per square foot.
Stainmaster
Recognized for superior stain resistance, Stainmaster carpets feature proprietary nylon fibers that resist wear and maintain appearance over time. Their PetProtect line specifically addresses pet-related issues with enhanced stain resistance and reduced pet hair attraction. Price range: $3.50-$12 per square foot.
Dream Weaver
Dream Weaver offers excellent value with PureColor fiber technology that provides fade resistance and easy cleaning. Their carpets typically come at lower price points while maintaining good quality standards. Price range: $1.50-$5 per square foot.
Top Brands for Laminate Flooring
Pergo
Pergo invented laminate flooring in 1977 and remains an industry leader, offering exceptional durability with their patented click-lock installation system. Their WetProtect technology provides waterproof surface protection. Price range: $2.50-$5 per square foot.
Armstrong
Armstrong laminate features impressive durability with VisionGuard wear layer protection. Their premium lines offer some of the most realistic wood visuals in the laminate market with embossed-in-register texturing that matches the wood grain appearance. Price range: $2-$5.50 per square foot.
Quick-Step
Known for innovation, Quick-Step offers Uniclic technology for gapless installation and impressive water resistance. Their NatureTEK Plus line provides superior waterproofing for kitchens and bathrooms. Price range: $2.50-$6 per square foot.
TrafficMaster
Home Depot’s exclusive brand offers budget-friendly laminate options with decent durability for light to medium traffic areas. TrafficMaster provides good value for homeowners on tight budgets or for rental properties. Price range: $0.80-$2.50 per square foot.
Pros and Cons of Carpet Flooring
Pros
- Comfort and warmth – provides soft cushioning underfoot and insulation in cold weather
- Excellent sound absorption – reduces noise levels between floors
- Wide variety of colors, patterns, and textures to match any décor
- Creates a cozy, comfortable atmosphere in bedrooms and living spaces
- Generally lower initial installation cost compared to many hard flooring options
- Provides safety benefits by reducing slip hazards and cushioning falls
Cons
- More challenging to clean thoroughly – can trap allergens, dust, and pet dander
- Susceptible to staining and requires more regular maintenance
- Shorter lifespan (7-10 years) than hard flooring options
- Not suitable for moisture-prone areas like bathrooms and kitchens
- Can fade over time when exposed to direct sunlight
- May require professional cleaning periodically to maintain appearance
Pros and Cons of Laminate Flooring
Pros
- Exceptional durability – resistant to scratches, impacts, and wear
- Easy maintenance – simple to clean with regular sweeping and occasional mopping
- Wide range of designs that realistically mimic hardwood, stone, and tile
- DIY-friendly installation with click-lock systems
- More moisture-resistant than hardwood (though not fully waterproof without specific treatments)
- Longer lifespan (15-25 years) than carpet with proper maintenance
Cons
- Harder underfoot – lacks the comfort and warmth of carpet
- Can sound hollow or create more noise when walked upon
- Cannot be refinished if damaged – individual planks must be replaced
- Lower-quality laminates may look artificial or feel too synthetic
- Susceptible to damage from standing water if not promptly cleaned
- Can chip or peel at the edges over time, especially in high-moisture environments
Which is Better for Different Rooms?
Bedrooms generally benefit from carpet’s warmth and comfort, creating a cozy atmosphere and providing noise reduction. The soft surface is pleasant for bare feet in the morning and creates a welcoming environment. High-quality carpets with stain resistance work particularly well in master bedrooms.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
For living rooms, either option can work well depending on your priorities. Laminate offers superior durability for high-traffic living spaces, particularly in homes with children or pets. However, carpet creates a warmer, more comfortable space for relaxing and can help define seating areas when used with area rugs.
Kitchens and bathrooms strongly favor laminate flooring due to moisture concerns. Water-resistant laminate provides practical protection against spills while offering easier cleaning. Even waterproof carpet options aren’t typically recommended for these consistently damp environments.
| Room | Recommended Option | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Bedroom | Carpet | Comfort, warmth, noise reduction |
| Living Room | Either (depends on lifestyle) | Balance of comfort vs. durability needs |
| Kitchen | Laminate | Moisture resistance, easy cleaning |
| Bathroom | Laminate (waterproof variety) | Water exposure, hygiene concerns |
| Basement | Laminate (waterproof variety) | Moisture concerns, temperature fluctuations |
Maintenance and Durability Comparison
Carpet maintenance requires regular vacuuming (2-3 times weekly in high-traffic areas) and professional deep cleaning every 12-18 months. Stains must be addressed immediately using appropriate carpet cleaners to prevent permanent damage. Most carpets have a lifespan of 5-15 years depending on quality and traffic levels.
Laminate flooring offers significantly easier maintenance with simple sweeping or vacuuming (using hard floor settings) and occasional damp mopping with manufacturer-approved cleaners. Avoid excessive water when cleaning laminate as it can damage the fiberboard core. Quality laminate typically lasts 15-25 years before needing replacement.
For homes with pets, laminate generally outperforms carpet in durability and cleaning ease. However, advances in stain-resistant carpet technology from brands like Stainmaster and Mohawk have improved carpet performance for pet owners. When comparing wear patterns, carpet may show paths in high-traffic areas while laminate maintains its appearance longer but may develop scratches over time.