The decision To Replace A Fiberglass Shower With Tile Involves Multiple Cost Variables, Timelines, And Design Choices. This Guide Breaks Down Typical Costs, Material Options, Labor Factors, And Ways To Save, Helping Homeowners Estimate A Realistic Budget For A Bathroom Renovation.
| Project Element | Typical Cost Range (USD) |
|---|---|
| Demolition & Disposal | $200 – $800 |
| Substrate Repair / Backer Board | $150 – $1,200 |
| Tile (Material Only) | $3 – $50+/sq ft |
| Waterproofing & Membranes | $100 – $600 |
| Labor (Tile Installation) | $500 – $3,000+ |
| Fixtures & Accessories | $50 – $1,500+ |
| Total Typical Project | $1,500 – $10,000+ |
Cost Overview For Replacing Fiberglass With Tile
Replacing A Fiberglass Shower With Tile Typically Costs Between $1,500 And $10,000 Or More, Depending On Size, Tile Choice, Labor Rates, And Scope Of Work. Most U.S. Homeowners Pay Between $3,000 And $6,000 For A Standard Shower Conversion Including Waterproofing And New Fixtures.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Primary Cost Components
Understanding The Main Cost Drivers Helps Create A Realistic Budget. The Primary Components Are Demolition, Substrate Preparation, Tile Materials, Waterproofing, Labor, And Any Additional Fixtures Or Plumbing Work.
Demolition And Disposal
Removal Of The Existing Fiberglass Unit Often Costs $200 To $800 Depending On Accessibility And Disposal Fees. If The Fiberglass Is Built-In Or Has Mold, Costs Can Rise Due To Careful Extraction And Remediation.
Substrate Repair And Backer Board
Tile Requires A Stable, Waterproof Substrate Like Cement Backer Board Or Waterproof Panels. Expect $150 To $1,200 For Repairs Or Replacing The Backer Board If Walls Or The Shower Pan Need Reinforcement.
Waterproofing And Membranes
Proper Waterproofing Is Essential To Prevent Leaks. Liquid Waterproofing, Sheet Membranes, Or Full-Pan Systems Typically Add $100 To $600 To The Project But Provide Long-Term Protection.
Tile Materials
Tile Costs Vary Widely: Porcelain And Ceramic Start Around $3 To $8 Per Square Foot, Natural Stone Like Marble Or Travertine Runs $10 To $50+ Per Square Foot. Higher-End Or Custom Tiles Increase Both Material And Labor Costs.
Labor And Installation
Tile Installation Is Labor-Intensive. Labor Typically Ranges From $5 To $15+ Per Square Foot For Standard Installations, Or $500 To $3,000+ For An Entire Shower Depending On Complexity And Regional Rates.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Plumbing And Fixtures
Moving Or Upgrading Fixtures Can Add $200 To $1,500+. Simple Fixture Swaps Are Inexpensive, But Relocating A Shower Valve Or Adding A New Niche/Bench Increases Plumbing Labor Costs Significantly.
Factors That Affect The Total Cost
Several Key Factors Influence The Final Price. Homeowners Should Account For Shower Size, Tile Type, Labor Rates In Their Area, Need For Subfloor Or Wall Repair, And Desired Extras Like Niches, Benches, Or Custom Tile Patterns.
Shower Size And Layout
Larger Showers Require More Tile, Waterproofing, And Labor. Converting A Tub-Shower Combo To A Walk-In Or Expanding The Footprint Raises Costs Substantially.
Tile Type And Finish
Matte Porcelain And Standard Ceramic Are Affordable, While Polished Natural Stone, Large Format Slabs, And Intricate Mosaics Increase Material And Installation Complexity.
Complexity Of Tile Pattern
Herringbone, Chevron, Diagonal Lays, Or Small Mosaic Work Require More Time And Skill, Increasing Labor Costs. Complex Patterns Can Double Labor Time.
Condition Of Existing Walls And Floor
If The Existing Fiberglass Removal Reveals Water Damage Or Mold, Repairs Can Add Hundreds Or Thousands To The Budget. Proper Repair Is Non-Negotiable For Durability.
Local Labor Rates And Contractor Experience
Urban Areas With High Living Costs Typically Have Higher Labor Rates. Experienced Tile Setters Charge Premiums But Deliver Better Longevity And Finish Quality.
Material Options And Comparative Costs
Selecting The Right Tile Balances Budget, Aesthetics, And Maintenance. Below Are Common Tile Options With Typical Cost Ranges To Help Choose Appropriately.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
| Tile Type | Cost Per Sq Ft (Material) | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ceramic | $3 – $7 | Affordable, Wide Styles, Easy To Cut | Less Durable Than Porcelain |
| Porcelain | $4 – $12 | Durable, Low Maintenance, Water-Resistant | Harder To Cut, Heavier |
| Natural Stone (Marble, Travertine) | $8 – $50+ | High-End Look, Unique Veining | Porous, Needs Sealing, Expensive |
| Glass Mosaic | $7 – $30+ | Vibrant Colors, Decorative | Costly Labor, Slippery When Wet |
| Large Format Tile | $8 – $30+ | Minimal Grout Lines, Modern Look | Requires Skilled Installers |
Labor: What To Expect And How It’s Priced
Labor Pricing Depends On Time, Complexity, And Skill. Tile Installers May Charge Per Square Foot Or Offer Project Quotes. Typical Labor Rates For A Shower Conversion Range From $500 To $3,000+.
Hourly Vs. Per-Square-Foot Pricing
Some Contractors Charge Hourly ($40–$100+/Hr), While Others Use Per-Sq-Ft Rates ($5–$15+/Sq Ft). Per-Sq-Ft Pricing Helps Compare Bids More Easily.
What Labor Covers
Labor Should Include Tile Layout, Cutting, Adhesive And Grout Application, Waterproofing Installation, And Cleanup. Confirm Whether The Quote Includes Substrate Repair And Fixture Reinstallation.
Typical Project Timeline
A Standard Fiberglass-To-Tile Shower Conversion Usually Takes 3 To 7 Days For A Typical Walk-In Or Stall Shower, And Up To 2 Weeks For More Complex Projects With Substrate Repairs Or Custom Tile Work.
Day-By-Day Breakdown
Day 1: Demolition And Disposal. Day 2: Substrate Repair And Backer Board Installation. Day 3: Waterproofing And Membrane Application. Day 4–5: Tile Setting. Day 6: Grouting And Cleanup. Day 7: Caulking And Fixture Reinstallation.
DIY Versus Hiring A Professional
DIY Can Save Money For Skilled Homeowners, But Tile Work Requires Precision To Avoid Leaks And Future Failures. Hiring A Professional Ensures Proper Waterproofing, Slope, And Long-Term Durability. For Most Homeowners, Professional Installation Is Recommended.
When DIY Makes Sense
DIY Works For Small Projects With Simple Tile Patterns And No Structural Repairs. Budget For Tools Like A Wet Saw, Tile Nippers, Trowels, And Waterproofing Materials.
When To Hire A Pro
Hire A Pro For Any Project Involving Plumbing Moves, Complex Layouts, Natural Stone, Or When The Existing Unit Shows Signs Of Water Damage Or Mold.
Permits, Codes, And Insurance Considerations
Local Building Codes May Require Permits For Plumbing Changes Or Structural Work. Check With Local Authorities Before Starting. Ensure Contractors Carry Liability Insurance And Workers’ Compensation To Avoid Homeowner Liability.
How To Get Accurate Estimates
Request Written Quotes From At Least Three Licensed Contractors. Provide Exact Measurements, Desired Tile Type, And Any Special Features. Ask For Detailed Breakdowns Covering Materials, Labor, Waterproofing, And Cleanup Costs.
Ways To Save Without Sacrificing Quality
There Are Several Strategies To Reduce Costs While Maintaining Reliability. Choose Midrange Tiles, Keep Existing Layout, And Shop Sales Or Overstock To Save Money.
- Buy Tile On Sale Or From Overstocks To Save 20–50%.
- Keep Shower Footprint And Valve Locations To Avoid Plumbing Moves.
- Choose Porcelain Or Standard Ceramic Over Natural Stone.
- Bundle Work With Other Bathroom Projects To Negotiate A Better Labor Rate.
- Hire A Skilled Installer For Critical Waterproofing, Then Do Some Finishing Work Yourself.
Common Upgrades And Their Costs
Popular Upgrades Include Installing A Shower Niche ($100–$400), Adding A Bench ($200–$800), Heated Floors Or Towel Bars ($500–$2,000+), And Frameless Glass Doors ($500–$2,500+). These Options Enhance Functionality And Resale Value.
Return On Investment And Resale Impact
Converting A Fiberglass Shower To Tile Often Improves Bathroom Appeal And Home Value, Especially When Using Quality Materials And Professional Installation. Homebuyers Frequently View Tile As A Premium Feature, Which Can Boost Marketability And Perceived Value.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Long Does A Tile Shower Last Compared To Fiberglass?
Properly Installed Tile With Good Waterproofing Can Last Decades, Often 25+ Years, Whereas Fiberglass Units May Show Wear Or Discoloration After 10–15 Years.
Is It Necessary To Waterproof Under The Tile?
Yes. Waterproofing Is Essential To Prevent Leaks And Structural Damage. Use A Membrane Or Liquid Waterproofing To Ensure Long-Term Protection.
Can The Tile Be Installed Directly Over Fiberglass?
Generally No. Fiberglass Is Not A Suitable Substrate For Tile. The Fiberglass Unit Should Be Removed And The Underlying Walls Prepared With Cement Backer Board Or Proper Waterproof Panels.
How Much Time Should Be Allotted For Curing And Use?
Allow Grout And Waterproofing To Cure As Recommended (Often 24–72 Hours) Before Using The Shower. Full Adhesive Cure Times May Vary By Product.
Actionable Next Steps
Measure The Shower Area, Choose A Tile Type, And Collect At Least Three Detailed Quotes From Licensed Installers. Prioritize Waterproofing And Substrate Integrity In Any Estimate. Document All Agreements In Writing, Including Timelines And Warranty Terms.
For Homeowners Seeking A Balance Of Durability And Value, Choosing Porcelain Tile With A Professional Installation And A Reliable Waterproofing System Offers The Best Long-Term Outcome.