Subway tile refers to the rectangular tile profile rather than a single material, and it can be made from either ceramic or porcelain. This article explains the key differences, how to identify material, performance characteristics, cost considerations, installation tips, and best uses for each type of subway tile.
| Feature | Ceramic Subway Tile | Porcelain Subway Tile |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Clay + glaze; fired at lower temperatures | Denser clay + higher firing temperature; often vitrified |
| Water Absorption | Higher (porous) | Lower (nearly impermeable) |
| Durability | Good for walls, light floors | Stronger; suitable for floors and high-traffic areas |
| Cost | Generally less expensive | Typically higher cost |
| Typical Uses | Bathrooms, kitchen backsplashes, walls | Floors, commercial spaces, wet areas |
What Is Subway Tile?
Subway tile is a rectangular, usually 3×6-inch profile that became popular with early 20th-century subway stations. It describes shape and style rather than a specific material, so both ceramic and porcelain can be produced as subway tiles.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Ceramic Versus Porcelain: Core Material Differences
Ceramic and porcelain are both made from clay but differ in composition and processing. Ceramic typically uses earthenware clays fired at lower temperatures, producing a lighter, more porous body with a glazed surface. Porcelain uses finer clays and higher firing temperatures, resulting in a denser, harder, and often vitrified body with much lower porosity.
How To Identify If Subway Tile Is Ceramic Or Porcelain
Several practical tests and visual checks help identify material. Look at the tile body color, water absorption, edge hardness, and glaze coverage. Porcelain bodies are usually uniform in color; ceramic bodies often show a different body color under the glaze. A simple water-drop test on an unglazed edge will show faster absorption for ceramic.
Visual And Physical Checks
Inspect an unglazed edge or cut. Porcelain will generally have a consistent color through the tile; ceramic often shows a lighter body beneath the glaze. Porcelain feels denser and colder to the touch.
Water Absorption Test
Place a drop of water on an unglazed edge; if it soaks in quickly, the tile is likely ceramic; if it beads and remains longer, it is likely porcelain. This test is simple but useful for non-lab environments.
Performance: Durability, Water Resistance, And Stain Resistance
Porcelain is stronger, denser, and more water-resistant, making it suitable for floors and wet areas. Ceramic performs well on walls, backsplashes, and low-traffic floors but is more porous and less chip-resistant.
Wear And Breakage Resistance
Porcelain’s higher density and vitrification confer superior wear and impact resistance. For high-traffic or heavy-use areas, porcelain subway tile is the preferred choice.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Moisture And Freeze Resistance
Porcelain has very low water absorption and performs well in freeze-thaw conditions. Ceramic’s higher absorption can lead to damage in freezing climates or highly moist exterior installations.
Appearance And Design Options
Both ceramic and porcelain subway tiles come in many glazes, finishes, and sizes. Ceramic is often available in glossy, colorful glazes and handmade looks, while porcelain offers stone-look and rectified edges for tight grout lines.
Glaze And Finish Varieties
Glazed ceramic provides rich color and sheen at a lower cost. Porcelain may use digital inkjet printing to replicate natural stone or textured looks with excellent realism.
Edge And Size Precision
Porcelain is commonly rectified—machined to exact dimensions—enabling very tight grout joints. Ceramic tiles are often non-rectified with slightly irregular edges for a classic look.
Cost Comparison And Value
Initial cost varies by brand and design. Ceramic subway tile is generally less expensive up front; porcelain usually commands a premium for performance and durability. Lifetime cost should factor in maintenance, replacement risk, and suitability for the installation.
Installation Cost Factors
Porcelain may cost more to install due to greater hardness and the need for specialized cutting tools. Contractor labor and tile-cutting complexity can raise total installed costs for porcelain.
Installation Recommendations For Subway Tile
For walls and backsplashes, ceramic subway tile is common and easier to cut. For floors or exterior/wet locations, choose porcelain. Proper substrate, waterproofing, and grout selection are critical regardless of tile material.
Grout And Waterproofing Guidance
Use epoxy or high-quality cement grout for wet areas; seal grout if necessary. Waterproofing membranes behind tiles in showers and backsplashes protect the structure regardless of tile type.
Need Flooring Help? Call 877-761-0420 for Local Quotes
Cutting And Tools
Porcelain requires a wet saw with a continuous-rim diamond blade for clean cuts. Ceramic can often be scored and snapped or cut with a tile nipper for small sections.
Maintenance And Care
Both tile types are easy to clean, but porcelain’s low porosity gives it an advantage for stain resistance and hygiene. Regular cleaning with mild detergents and periodic grout care keep both tiles looking new.
Cleaning Recommendations
Avoid abrasive cleaners on glossy ceramic glazes to prevent micro-abrasions. Porcelain tolerates stronger cleaners but still benefits from gentle routine maintenance.
Best Uses For Ceramic Subway Tile
Ceramic subway tile is ideal for interior walls, kitchen backsplashes, bathroom walls, and decorative accents. It balances cost, aesthetic variety, and sufficient performance for these applications.
Best Uses For Porcelain Subway Tile
Porcelain subway tile is suited for floors, commercial spaces, high-moisture areas, and exterior installations where durability and low water absorption are important. It offers long-term resilience in demanding environments.
Environmental And Sustainability Considerations
Both ceramic and porcelain production consume energy, but manufacturers increasingly use recycled content and energy-efficient kilns. Choosing locally manufactured tile and recycled-material products reduces carbon footprint.
Common Misconceptions About Subway Tile Material
A frequent misconception is that subway tile equals ceramic. In reality, subway refers to tile shape; both ceramic and porcelain subway tiles are widely available.
How To Choose: Questions To Ask Before Buying
Consider location, traffic, moisture, budget, and desired look. Ask suppliers about water absorption rating, PEI rating for durability, rectification, and recommended grout. Matching tile properties to the installation is essential for performance and value.
FAQ: Quick Answers
Is Subway Tile Always Ceramic? No; subway tile can be ceramic or porcelain.
Which Is Better For Floors? Porcelain, because it is denser and more wear-resistant. Porcelain is the preferred choice for floor applications.
Can Ceramic Be Used In Showers? Yes, on walls and backsplashes; however, porcelain may be a safer choice for wet floors or exterior showers.
Resources And Standards To Look For
Check ANSI and ASTM standards for tile performance, PEI ratings for abrasion, and water absorption classifications. These standards help compare products objectively and ensure suitability for intended use.
Summary Guidance For American Homeowners And Designers
When choosing subway tile, balance aesthetic goals with functional requirements. Choose ceramic for interior wall applications where cost and variety matter; choose porcelain where durability, low porosity, and floor use are priorities.
| Decision Factor | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Walls/Backsplash | Ceramic Often Preferred For Cost And Variety |
| Floors/High Traffic/Wet Floors | Porcelain Recommended For Durability |
| Budget | Ceramic Lower Upfront Cost; Consider Lifetime Value |
| Aesthetic Variety | Both Offer Many Finishes; Porcelain Excels At Stone Look |